The Scotsman Hotel Edinburgh, Edinburgh

I had a delightful stay at the hotel, with stunning views of the Edinburgh skyline, including the Castle, from my room's huge windows. The service was excellent, although I noticed some minor issues with basic hotel procedures. The location couldn't have been better, being right in the heart of everything Edinburgh has to offer. The dining experience was satisfactory, with good options available. Overall, a wonderful experience that I highly recommend.

I couldn't ask for a better location! The hotel sits right across the street from the Waverly train station, making it super convenient for exploring Edinburgh. The rooms offer a view over Scotts Monument that is truly unforgettable. However, there were some issues with service confusion throughout my stay.

This hotel offers a lovely view from the rooms and a great location near the center of Edinburgh. The service was exceptional, with friendly and helpful staff. The dining experience provided both hot and cold foods; however, the bathtub shower and overall luxury fell slightly short of a 5-star experience.

I had a mixed experience at the hotel. The rooms were nice with some great views, but they were a bit warm at night. The service was a bit inconsistent, but they tried their best to make our stay special. The location was convenient with easy access to public transport. The dining options were good, and I enjoyed the extras available. Overall, a decent stay with some room for improvement.

I had an amazing stay at the hotel with a beautiful view of Calton Hill from my room. The rooms were kept impeccably clean and were equipped with a separate bathtub and shower, offering stunning views. The service was top-notch, with friendly and accommodating staff, especially the reception and breakfast waiter. The location was perfect, within easy reach of public transport and walking distance to all the key attractions in the center of Edinburgh. The dining experience was delightful with a variety of cooked-to-order options like Eggs Benedict and Pancakes included in the rate. The facilities were excellent, making my stay truly enjoyable overall.

I couldn't have asked for a better stay! The hotel had a cozy atmosphere with beautiful wood paneling in the rooms and a lovely view. The seating areas were a nice touch, but the intentional bad view was a bit off-putting. The service was exceptional, with all staff being super friendly and accommodating, and our waiter at breakfast went above and beyond to make our meals special. The location was ideal, close to everything we wanted to see, including the Waverly train station and the castle. However, the Wi-Fi quality was surprisingly poor for a capital city. Dining was a delight with a variety of tasty dishes, and the included cooked-to-order options were a real treat.

The hotel offers a breathtaking view over Scotts Monument from the rooms. The original features add a touch of charm, but the separate bathtub and shower are a nice modern touch. While the price is on the higher side, the experience is definitely worth it for the lovely views and amenities provided.

I found the hotel to have lovely rooms with a pleasant view, although the experience didn't quite meet a 5-star standard. The lighting was a bit dim, but I appreciated the touch of Arran soaps in the bathroom. The staff tried hard and provided good service, with a few minor hiccups from the receptionist. The location was superb, right in the center of everything and conveniently across from the Waverley train station. The dining experience offered good drinks and a great view of Princes Street. The facilities were satisfactory, with a mix of positive and negative aspects.

The hotel has some unique room features like a lovely roll-top bath in a separate turret. However, the windows were dirty, and there was some inconvenience with splitting the bed into a twin. The service was exceptional without being intrusive, and the location next to Waverly train station is convenient for public transport. The dining offers delicious cooked-to-order options, although there seemed to be a focus on gluten-free meals. The facilities were satisfactory, offering room service and laundry services.

The hotel is ideally located in Edinburgh's Old Town with easy access to public transport. The rooms are cozy and offer a slightly larger wardrobe, but unfortunately, a view of scaffolding. The service was a bit confused but the staff at the reception and breakfast was extremely friendly and helpful. The brasserie on-site offers excellent dining options. Despite minor setbacks, the overall experience was pleasant and convenient.